Football recruiting intelligence
Football Roster Forecast
2027 HS Rank: 159
2027 Overall Rank: 159
Follow Colgate University recruiting, transfer portal activity, personnel, roster forecasts, and football news.
177High School Recruiting
2Transfers
Colgate Football Office
Roster Outlook
Published roster pool, sorted alphabetically within positions. Multi-position players are grouped by their first listed role. Depth order, scholarship status and remaining eligibility are not verified; planning changes are your assumptions.
Colgate Athletics · 2026 football rosterUpdated 2026-09-18Loading saved plan
103Published roster members
0/25Your 2026 lineup assignments
27Coaching and support staff
12Scheduled games
Roster pool · offense
Alphabetical examples · no depth ranking.
Published roster pool · position placement is illustrative
Academic class is reproduced from Colgate Athletics. It does not establish remaining NCAA eligibility or scholarship status.
| Player | Pos. | Academic class | Ht / Wt | Hometown / previous school |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 #0 Joe KellyInstagram | DL | Jr. | 6-2 / 290 | Wilmette, Ill.Loyola Academy |
 #1 Chief MontalvoInstagram | WR | Jr. | 5-11 / 190 | Brooklyn, N.Y.Wyoming Seminary |
 #2 Winston MooreInstagram | WR | Sr. | 5-11 / 190 | St. Louis, Mo.MICDS |
 #3 Taytum JohnsonInstagram | DB | Jr. | 5-10 / 185 | Katy, TexasCinco Ranch |
 #4 Christian Magliacano | LB | Jr. | 6-2 / 235 | Berkeley Heights, N.J.St. Joseph Preparatory |
 #5 Cole FultonInstagram | RB | Jr. | 6-1 / 220 | Poland, OhioPoland Seminary |
 #6 Tymir WynnInstagram | DB | Sr. | 6-0 / 195 | Columbus, OhioKipp |
 #7 Kam PhillipsInstagram | WR | Jr. | 6-2 / 197 | North Chesterfield, Va.Saint Michael the Archangel |
 #8 Kaleb Alexander | DB | Sr. | 6-0 / 190 | Palmdale, Calif.Highland |
 #8 Peyton Way | WR | Fy. | 6-0 / 195 | New Hartford, N.Y.New Hartford |
 #9 Josh Faraimo | DB | Fy. | 6-1 / 220 | Oceanside, Calif.Cathedral Catholic |
 #9 Hudson Reasor | WR | Fy. | 6-3 / 205 | Fort Worth, TexasAll Saints Episcopal School |
 #10 Jadon Sultz | QB | Fy. | 6-0 / 200 | Austin, TexasMcNeil |
 #10 Justyn Toler | DB | Sr. | 6-2 / 190 | Toledo, OhioSt. John's Jesuit |
 #11 Joey Tomasso | QB | So. | 6-1 / 205 | Waverly, N.Y.Waverly |
 #12 Aleks SitkowskiInstagram | TE | Jr. | 6-4 / 260 | Old Bridge, N.J.Watchung Hills |
 #13 Dylan Lee | WR | Fy. | 6-1 / 175 | Union, Ky.Ryle High School |
 #13 Antwaune RodgersInstagram | DB | So. | 6-0 / 195 | Greenbelt, Md.Eleanor Roosevelt |
 #14 Matt FoglerInstagram | WR | So. | 6-4 / 215 | Cincinnati, OhioArchbishop Moeller |
 #15 Jake StearneyInstagram | QB | Sr. | 6-3 / 210 | Chicago, Ill.Loyola Academy |
 #16 JJ Johnson | DB | Jr. | 6-1 / 185 | LaGrange, Ga.LaGrange |
 #17 Jackson KilburgInstagram | QB | So. | 6-4 / 225 | Nashville, Tenn.Kent School |
 #17 Julian Mellado | DB | Fy. | 5-11 / 180 | Miami, Fla.The Hun School of Princeton |
 #18 Trooper PriceInstagram | LB | Sr. | 6-3 / 230 | Ponte Vedra, Fla.Ponte Vedra |
 #18 Elias Redlew | WR | Fy. | 6-2 / 195 | San Pedro, Calif.San Pedro |
 #19 Grant KinneeInstagram | WR | So. | 6-3 / 185 | Waterville, OhioAnthony Wayne |
 #20 Chase Jarrett | DB | So. | 6-0 / 200 | Tampa, Fla.Plant |
 #21 Danny ShabanInstagram | RB | Jr. | 6-0 / 221 | Redding, Conn.Joel Barlow |
 #22 Kenny LangstonInstagram | DB | Jr. | 6-0 / 205 | Wilmette, Ill.Loyola Academy |
 #23 Reece AllanInstagram | DB | Jr. | 6-3 / 206 | Seminole, Fla.Osceola Fundamental |
 #24 Jordan EdgecombInstagram | LB | So. | 6-2 / 225 | Atlanta, Ga.Christ School |
 #24 O'Shea Faison | RB | Fy. | 6-0 / 215 | Sanford, Fla.Lake Mary HS |
 #25 Kyle MessinaInstagram | RB | So. | 6-1 / 205 | Sayville, N.Y.Sayville |
 #26 Griffin GentnerInstagram | DB | Sr. | 6-0 / 180 | New Canaan, Conn.New Canaan |
 #27 VJ BullardInstagram | RB | Jr. | 5-9 / 200 | Fishersville, Va.Harrisonburg |
 #28 Caleb Naumann | RB | Fy. | 5-11 / 214 | Cincinnati, OhioArchbishop McNicholas |
 #29 Connor RowlisonInstagram | DB | Jr. | 6-1 / 205 | Avon, OhioAvon |
 #30 Dawson Batemon | DB | Fy. | 6-3 / 197 | Atlanta, Ga.Marist School |
 #31 Josh StinespringInstagram | DB | Sr. | 6-0 / 190 | Baltimore, Md.St. Paul's School |
 #32 Hal NiendorffInstagram | DB | So. | 6-0 / 190 | Knoxville, Tenn.Webb School |
 #33 Talib Shakir | DB | Fy. | 6-0 / 193 | Camden, N.J.Camden |
 #34 Paul-Marie DoguiInstagram | LB | Jr. | 6-2 / 235 | Québec City, QuébecMcCallie School |
 #35 Connor PhelpsInstagram | LB | Jr. | 6-3 / 235 | Oklahoma City, Okla.Casady |
 #36 Tripp Kellenberger | DB | Fy. | 6-0 / 190 | Lexington, TexasLexington High School |
 #37 Tyler FontenotInstagram | K/P | Jr. | 6-2 / 215 | Falls Church, Va.Bishop O'Connell |
 #38 Zach JonesInstagram | LB | Jr. | 6-1 / 213 | London, OhioLondon |
 #39 Blake Turner | DB | Fy. | 6-3 / 190 | Royersford, Pa.Spring-Ford High School |
 #40 Justin Davis | LB | Fy. | 6-2 / 230 | Wall, N.J.Wall High School |
 #41 Reid Burke | DB | Jr. | 5-10 / 190 | Alexandria, Va.Phillips Exeter |
 #42 Penn PictonInstagram | LB | So. | 6-2 / 215 | Cincinnati, OhioIndian Hill |
 #43 Jeb KoettingInstagram | LB | So. | 6-2 / 230 | Leawood, Kan.Rockhurst |
 #44 Justin TedimInstagram | DL | Sr. | 6-3 / 245 | Davie, Fla.Western |
 #45 Noah PfafflinInstagram | LB | Jr. | 6-2 / 225 | Western Springs, Ill.Lyons Township |
 #46 Kyle Kirby | LB | Fy. | 6-2 / 225 | Granville, OhioGranville |
 #47 Michael Hill | TE | Fy. | 6-4 / 235 | Deerfield, N.Y.Whitesboro |
 #48 Carson WilkieInstagram | PK/P | Jr. | 6-0 / 180 | Atlanta, Ga.The Westminster School |
 #49 Nathan Judy | LB | Fy. | 6-3 / 230 | Hudson, OhioHudson High School |
 #50 Declan NortonInstagram | LB | So. | 6-2 / 230 | Lyndhurst, OhioWalsh Jesuit |
 #51 Cole ToddingsInstagram | LB | So. | 6-2 / 230 | Barnegat, N.J.Barnegat |
 #52 Will DoddsInstagram | LS | So. | 6-2 / 202 | Cresskill, N.J.Bergen Catholic |
 #53 Patrick CramerInstagram | LS | Sr. | 6-2 / 215 | Countryside, Ill.Lyons Township |
 #54 Luca Konrad | LB | Fy. | 6-2 / 225 | Endwell, N.Y.Maine-Endwell |
 #55 Anthony Pignatello | LB | Fy. | 6-2 / 225 | Hermosa Beach, Calif.Serra Gardena |
 #56 Matthew SmithInstagram | OL | So. | 6-3 / 285 | Rumson, N.J.Rumson Fair Haven Regional |
 #57 Payton HawkinsInstagram | DL | Jr. | 6-3 / 275 | Bixby, Okla.Bixby |
 #58 Grant Siebert | OL | Fy. | 6-2 / 285 | Arlington, Va.Washington & Liberty High School |
 #60 Sean HaneyInstagram | OL | Sr. | 6-2 / 295 | Torrance, Calif.St. John Bosco |
 #61 Dominic Moe WernerInstagram | OL | Jr. | 6-6 / 275 | Kansas City, Kan.Bishop Miege |
 #62 Kevin George | OL | Fy. | 6-2 / 290 | Whitesboro, N.Y.Whitesboro |
 #63 Michael Milenkovski | DL | Fy. | 6-3 / 270 | Blacklick, OhioColumbus Academy |
 #64 Andy VoisinetInstagram | OL | Jr. | 6-5 / 290 | Olmsted Falls, OhioOlmsted Falls |
 #65 Dawson RoddInstagram | DL | So. | 6-2 / 310 | Andover, Kan.Andover Central |
 #66 Adam MurphyInstagram | OL | So. | 6-6 / 290 | Brielle, N.J.Manasquan |
 #67 Gerard Gearity | OL | Fy. | 6-4 / 295 | Saint Cloud, Fla.The First Academy |
 #68 Harrison BrownInstagram | OL | Jr. | 6-6 / 295 | Katonah, N.Y.Archbishop Stepinac |
 #69 Philip Tabasso | DL | Jr. | 6-2 / 295 | Phoenixville, Pa.Malvern Preparatory |
 #70 Bobby GalindoInstagram | OL | Jr. | 6-3 / 290 | Rockville Centre, N.Y.South Side |
 #71 Thomas Gearity | OL | So. | 6-4 / 305 | Saint Cloud, Fla.Osceola |
 #72 David SikpeInstagram | OL | Jr. | 6-4 / 295 | Canal Winchester, OhioCanal Winchester |
 #73 RJ Stamm | OL | Fy. | 6-5 / 285 | Windermere, Fla.Dr. Phillips High School |
 #74 Will MarshallInstagram | OL | Sr. | 6-5 / 297 | Flower Mound, TexasFlower Mound |
 #76 Ryan SteinbrinkInstagram | OL | Sr. | 6-4 / 295 | Columbus, OhioCanal Winchester |
 #77 Jacob HoffmanInstagram | OL | So. | 6-3 / 290 | Macomb, Mich.De La Salle Collegiate |
 #78 Matthew PerdueInstagram | OL | So. | 6-2 / 295 | Long Beach, Calif.St. John Boscoe |
 #79 Ryan MurphyInstagram | OL | Jr. | 6-6 / 310 | Copiague, N.Y.St. Anthony's |
 #80 Michael StevensonInstagram | TE | So. | 6-6 / 250 | Carroll, OhioBloom-Carroll |
 #81 Mike BaloghInstagram | TE | Jr. | 6-4 / 240 | Elyria, OhioSt. Edward |
 #82 Austin Teasley | WR | Fy. | 6-2 / 190 | Cheyenne, Wy.Cheyenne Central |
 #83 P.J. HolmesInstagram | WR | So. | 6-2 / 210 | Downingtown, Pa.Malvern Prep |
 #84 Michael Casey | WR | So. | 5-9 / 180 | Shoreham, N.Y.Shoreham-Wading River |
 #85 Chuck VolansInstagram | TE | Sr. | 6-4 / 240 | Schenectady, N.Y.CBA Albany |
 #86 Nick ModugnoInstagram | WR | Sr. | 6-4 / 180 | Morristown, N.J.Delbarton |
 #87 Chuck Haight | WR | Fy. | 6-5 / 200 | Delhi, N.Y.Deerfield Academy |
 #88 Quinn Connors | TE | Fy. | 6-6 / 235 | Fort Lauderdale, Fla.Saint Andrew's School |
 #89 Bryce LubinInstagram | TE | Jr. | 6-1 / 240 | Summit, N.J.Summit |
 #90 Jack Gyimesi | TE | Fy. | 6-3 / 230 | Fair Haven, N.J.Rumson-Fair Haven Regional HS |
 #91 Martin GearyInstagram | DL | So. | 6-3 / 290 | Ponte Vedra, Fla.Ponte Vedra |
 #92 Brock WinsettInstagram | DL | Sr. | 6-4 / 245 | Allen, TexasAllen |
 #93 Grant ArgiroInstagram | PK | So. | 6-2 / 200 | Wexford, Pa.Pine-Richland |
 #94 Gage Lawrence | DL | Fy. | 6-4 / 245 | Alpharetta, Ga.Milton High School |
 #95 Luke VogelerInstagram | PK | Sr. | 6-3 / 200 | Caledonia, Mich.Caledonia |
 #95 Jackson Whitten | DL | Fy. | 6-4 / 280 | Mount Olivet, Ky.Bracken County HS |
 #96 Adam DeSantisInstagram | DL | Jr. | 6-3 / 265 | Endwell, N.Y.Maine-Endwell |